In Search of the Moon

Posted By Pamela on Jul 5, 2007 | 3 comments

161399main_orion_lander.jpgTonight I decided to whiplash my brain. After a nice dinner with friends, my husband and I settled in to watch TV. In preparation for the holiday weekend, we rented some DVDs, including the turn of the century classic Fight Club. At the end of that violent, twisted, pre-9/11 movie, I decided to break my brain by switching on “The Universe: The Moon,” a violent, straight-forward, current TV show. This latest episode of the History Channel’s television series has a few really scientifically confusing images, but does a really nice job mentioning all the possible ways the Moon could have formed. (Astronomy Cast also covered this topic in this episode.)

At the very end of the episode, they made a brief mention of the current White House’s New Vision for Space Exploration Program. The gist of this plan goes something like this:

  1. NASA is <1% of the U.S. budget and will stay that way.
  2. The Space Station will be completed by 2010
  3. Between 2015 and 2020 we will send men back to the moon.
  4. “The funding added for exploration will total $12 billion over the next five years. Most of this added funding for new exploration will come from reallocation of $11 billion that is currently within the five-year total NASA budget of $86 billion.”

Let me try and explain that last item a little bit better. Imagine you have a food budget of $86 dollars per week to feed a family and at the end of each week you usually end up having to choose between putting back your daughter’s favorite and healthy granola and asking her to go without, or putting back your son’s favorite fruit juice and asking him to go without. You get by as best you can, you know your children will never have a chance to be obese, but you are glad they will at least get to each have their favorites at least now and then. Now, out of no where, your boss gives you a dollar and tells you that you are required to spend the dollar he gives you and $11 out of your $86 budget each week to buy celery. While the celery is nutritious and will get eaten, it isn’t what your children want and it won’t help their already slight frames.

In this parable the children are the astronomy and planetary science communities who desperately dream of space born telescopes and exploratory planetary probes. The celery is the space manned space program. The rest I leave to your imagination.

I strongly believe that there are certain things that it is appropriate for the government to fund and things that really belong in the private sector. Manned exploration for the sake of manned exploration because, well, it’s cool to put people in space, is one of those things that belongs in the private sector. Manned space flight for the sake of science and doing things that push the bounds of learning that we have no way of doing without risking lives – I can actually support doing that with tax money.

Going to the Moon and Mars is something we can totally do with robots if we want to do science.

And going to the Moon and Mars is something people will do eventually without presidential edicts. More powerful than the presidential edict, which really was just another mostly unfunded mandate, I think was the announcement of a new X-Prize that challenges the commercial space agencies to build lunar landers. I see this as the first step in challenging the likes of Burt Rutan, Richard Branson and Robert Bigelow to expand the empires beyond the surface of the Earth.

But, despite the success of the Ansari X-Prize and the flight of SpaceShipOne very few people actually know about the commercial space programs. One of my favorite things to do is ask people if they know about Virgin Galactic , Bigelow Aerospace, or Space Services Inc, the three companies that seem to land in the news most often. Very few people have heard of these companies, and everyone seems to think what they are doing is cool once they hear about it. I’m not sure what needs to be done to better get the word out about this new breed of start ups.

So, have you heard about these companies outside of this blog? Where? What did those people do write that caught your attention and helped you remember the commercial space race?


  1. I’ve heard of them because I’m interested in these things. I’m also good at spotting the tiny astronomy/space related articles in the local newspapers.

    Vergin Galactic being the one that got most attention over here but I dout more than 2 people in my old class knew what it was.

  2. I mentioned Genesis 2 as one of the news items at this past monday’s astronomy club. I embellished with the stated goal of eventually putting up a space hotel, and the concept that inflatable structures are likely really alot easier and cheaper to get into orbit than big tin cans. I did not mention the ISS, how much money has been spent on it, or that LLNL proposed that the ISS be constructed with inflatables really quite early on.

    Despite being a room full of people who are self selected as interested in astronomy and space, it seemed as if it was news to most.

  3. Dear Pam
    Hope you and your husband had a wonderful 4th this year…
    a few random thoughts…
    I really wish you teachers made a ton more money..I really respect you for what you do.
    My best bud in the world teaches 5th grade math..
    The pay scale suks..Sorry.
    Without you and other ‘instructors’, where would we be?
    2) think about a book..there is always room for someone as smart as you that can explain the universe to people as dumb as me 🙂
    3) Someday you may run a major sweet is that?
    4) You may have a student that someday runs a major observatory…
    5) I leave your blog now for awhile..Our young son, a marine, leaves us sunday for california and then Iraq..Our family will live in turmoil, fear, hope and prayers for many forthcoming months.. and my dreams of the stars will be on standby for the dream of safety and of this ugly world we call earth and it’s wars.
    Bless you Pam..keep fighting the fight to bring the vision of the heavens to us on terra firma.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.